Soft cheeses and summer heat can affect shipping; read each shop’s policy before you order. Hours change by season — confirm on the official site.
Interlaken
Lively Run Dairy
A family creamery that has been making cheese in the Finger Lakes since 1982 and describes itself as one of the first farmstead dairies in New York. Cheeses are made at the Interlaken farm; milk comes from partner farms in the region and beyond. Cayuga Blue is a pasteurized goat-milk blue named for the nearby lake. Shop and farm visits are on the official site.
Visit the official site
Waterloo
Muranda Cheese Company
Muranda Holsteins was founded by Tom and Nancy Murray in 1991; the family started Muranda Cheese Company in late 2007 to sell their cow’s-milk cheeses directly. The tasting room is at 3075 Route 96, Waterloo. The official site lists pasteurized cheeses including British Cheddar, Red Buddy, and Muranda Blue, and has an online shop.
Visit the official site
A bottle from a nearby winery or cidery makes a natural pairing — see Keuka, Seneca, and Cayuga and Canandaigua.
Picnic and tasting extras
The makers above sell the gifts themselves. If you also need a simple carrier or a board for a tasting at home, these Amazon searches are a practical add-on — not a substitute for a bottle or a wheel from the farm.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Amazon links on this page use the site tag and are disclosed on the disclosure page.
More gift guides
2026 holiday gifts
Wine-country gifts
Local food gifts
Lake-life gifts
Art & local gifts
Keuka Lake
Seneca Lake
Cayuga & Canandaigua
Maple
Crafts & the Penn Yan market