Canandaigua
Timber Trails Forest Farm
A family-owned 250-acre farm producing organic, wood-fired maple syrup at 5585 County Road 33.
Visit the official siteLocal food gifts
Maple, farmstead cheese, orchard juice, and coffee roasted in the region — gifts that usually ship more easily than wine.
These are producers that sell from their own sites. Confirm current products, shipping rules, and holiday cutoffs on each official site before you order; we do not list prices.
Canandaigua
A family-owned 250-acre farm producing organic, wood-fired maple syrup at 5585 County Road 33.
Visit the official siteNaples
A sugarhouse on the Wohlschlegel estate in the Canandaigua Lake watershed; the official site describes more than 4,200 taps.
Visit the official siteMecklenburg
Small-batch maple syrup from a farm between Ithaca and Watkins Glen with a hand-built field-stone sugar shack.
Visit the official siteInterlaken
A family creamery making cheese in the Finger Lakes since 1982, including Cayuga Blue, a pasteurized goat-milk blue.
Visit the official siteWaterloo
A family farmstead making its own cow’s-milk cheeses, with a tasting room at 3075 Route 96 and an online shop.
Visit the official siteGeneva
Three generations of the Nicholson family have farmed in the Finger Lakes; the company presses juices from apples it grows and sources locally. Products and where to buy are on the official site.
Visit the official siteFinger Lakes region
A coffee roaster that says it has been roasting in the Finger Lakes for more than 25 years, with single origins, blends, and flavored coffees sold from its official shop.
Visit the official siteInterlaken
A working farm and cidery; cider, food, and gifts are sold from the site. Cider ships under alcohol rules.
Visit the official siteIf you are putting together a breakfast or cheese box yourself, these Amazon searches cover the non-food pieces.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Amazon links on this page use the site tag and are disclosed on the disclosure page.
For a gift that hangs on the wall instead of going in the pantry, Lakes & Tiers Gallery is a new online marketplace for original art and limited-edition prints from Finger Lakes and Southern Tier artists, browsable by lake or by the Southern Tier. Sales are opening soon; you can join the waitlist to hear when buying opens.
Are you a Finger Lakes or Southern Tier artist? The gallery is taking applications from founding artists — listing is free. See join as a founding artist.
Lakes & Tiers Gallery shares an owner with this guide. We do not earn a commission on gallery sales.
2026 holiday gifts Wine-country gifts Lake-life gifts Art & local gifts Keuka Lake Seneca Lake Cayuga & Canandaigua Maple Cheese Crafts & the Penn Yan market