Part of the Live Finger Lakes networkExplore the region ›

Holiday gifts, 2026

2026 Finger Lakes holiday gift guide

Wine, maple, cheese, cider, and a late-November market day — a mid-November guide to real Finger Lakes makers, with links to official shops. No display ads, and no made-up prices or reviews.

Mid-November is when shipping calendars and last market Saturdays start to matter. This page groups already-verified Finger Lakes makers by the kind of holiday gift they are good for. Confirm current bottles, baskets, and delivery cutoffs on each official site before you order.

If you are looking for a calendar of visits and events rather than a mail-order gift, Living on Keuka’s 2026 Keuka Lake and Finger Lakes holiday events guide is a real, currently published list. For makers from the rest of the state, see the sibling Shop New York State 2026 holiday guide.

Wine for the holiday table

A Finger Lakes Riesling, a traditional-method sparkler, or a small-production Cayuga bottle is a strong host gift — if it can legally ship to the recipient. Alcohol shipping is restricted by state law; read the winery site. Fuller lists are on the Keuka, Seneca, and Cayuga and Canandaigua pages.

Hammondsport, Keuka Lake

Dr. Konstantin Frank Winery

A pioneering Finger Lakes estate. The official site describes Riesling, other still wines, and traditional-method sparkling wine, plus tastings and shipping.

Visit the official site

Dundee, Seneca Lake

Hermann J. Wiemer Vineyard

A Seneca Lake estate widely known for Riesling and other wines from its own vineyards. The official site has estate information and an online shop.

Visit the official site

Union Springs, eastern Cayuga

Heart & Hands Wine Company

A boutique winery making still and sparkling wines from Pinot Noir, Aligoté, Chardonnay, Riesling, and other cool-climate varieties. Visitor information and the shop are on the official site.

Visit the official site

Hammondsport, Keuka Lake

Heron Hill Winery

John and Jo Ingle planted grapes here in 1972; the official story dates the winery itself to 1977. Shop and visit details are on the official site.

Visit the official site

A Finger Lakes breakfast box you can assemble

Competing gift shops often sell a ready-made breakfast basket. You can build the same idea yourself from official farm shops: a bottle of maple, a cheese, and a stop at a cidery or dairy. We do not set prices or claim a bundle; each producer sells its own goods.

Canandaigua

Timber Trails Forest Farm

A family-owned 250-acre farm producing organic, wood-fired maple syrup at 5585 County Road 33. The official sugar shop is the current catalog.

Visit the official site

Naples

The Naples Maple Farm

A sugarhouse on the Wohlschlegel estate in the Canandaigua Lake watershed. The official site describes more than 4,200 taps and sells bottles and assortments from the official store.

Visit the official site

Mecklenburg

Steinhaus Farm

Henry and Grit Phelps run a small farm between Ithaca and Watkins Glen, with a hand-built field-stone sugar shack. The official site describes small-batch maple syrup and how to order.

Visit the official site

Interlaken

Lively Run Dairy

A family creamery making cheese in the Finger Lakes since 1982, including Cayuga Blue, a pasteurized goat-milk blue. Shop and farm visits are on the official site.

Visit the official site

Waterloo

Muranda Cheese Company

A farmstead making its own cow’s-milk cheeses, with a tasting room at 3075 Route 96, Waterloo. The official site has an online shop.

Visit the official site

Cider and spirits

Interlaken

Finger Lakes Cider House

A working farm and cidery at 4017 Hickok Road. The official site describes traditional ciders from cider-specific apples and a specialty in the champagne method. Cider, food, and gifts are sold from the site — and shipping follows the same alcohol rules as wine.

Visit the official site

Burdett

Finger Lakes Distilling

A New York spirits distillery in the Finger Lakes, with whiskey and other spirits, tastings, and a shop. Shipping depends on where you live.

Visit the official site

A late-November market day in Penn Yan

If you can shop in person, The Windmill Farm & Craft Market sits just south of Penn Yan on Route 14A (3900 New York 14A). The official site says it is open every Saturday from the third Saturday in April through the last Saturday in November, and also on Memorial Day, July 4th observed, Labor Day, and Black Friday, from 8:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m., with free admission and parking. In 2026, the late-season dates are Saturday, November 28, and Black Friday, November 27. Confirm hours on the official site before you drive; vendor lineups change.

More background is on the crafts page. If you also need a simple carrier or a board for a tasting at home, the searches below are a practical add-on — not a substitute for a bottle or a wheel from the farm.

Local art gifts

For a gift that hangs on the wall instead of going in the pantry, Lakes & Tiers Gallery is a new online marketplace for original art and limited-edition prints from Finger Lakes and Southern Tier artists, browsable by lake or by the Southern Tier. Sales are opening soon; you can join the waitlist to hear when buying opens.

Are you a Finger Lakes or Southern Tier artist? The gallery is taking applications from founding artists — listing is free. See join as a founding artist.

Lakes & Tiers Gallery shares an owner with this guide. We do not earn a commission on gallery sales.

Picnic and tasting extras

The makers above sell the gifts themselves. If you also need a simple carrier or a board for a tasting at home, these Amazon searches are a practical add-on — not a substitute for a bottle or a wheel from the farm.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Amazon links on this page use the site tag and are disclosed on the disclosure page.

Holiday questions

Can I ship Finger Lakes wine as a holiday gift?

Sometimes, but not everywhere. Wine, cider, and spirits shipments are limited by state law. Each producer’s official site will tell you where it can ship. If a bottle cannot go to the recipient, send maple or cheese instead, or plan a tasting for a visit.

When is the Windmill Farm & Craft Market open in late 2026?

The official site says the market is open every Saturday from the third Saturday in April through the last Saturday in November, and also on Memorial Day, July 4th observed, Labor Day, and Black Friday, from 8:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. In 2026, that late-season calendar is Saturday, November 28, plus Black Friday, November 27. Confirm hours and any weather closings on the official site before you drive.

Where can I find Finger Lakes holiday events, not just gifts?

Living on Keuka publishes a 2026 Keuka Lake and Finger Lakes holiday events guide. That site is a related lake-living guide, not a shop. Use it for calendars and visits; use this site for makers you can order from or stop in on.

Is Finger Lakes Shop a store?

No. It is an independent editorial gift guide. We do not sell products, invent prices, or publish ratings. Links go to official maker sites so you can see current bottles, shipping rules, and prices there.

This is an independent guide, not a store and not a tourism-bureau website. See About and Disclosure.

More gift guides

Wine-country gifts Local food gifts Lake-life gifts Art & local gifts Keuka Lake Seneca Lake Cayuga & Canandaigua Maple Cheese Crafts & the Penn Yan market

A Live Finger Lakes network site