Art makes a gift that stays tied to a place. These are galleries and markets we verified on their own sites. Hours, artists, and stock change; confirm before you drive.
Downtown Naples
Artizanns
Artizanns describes itself as the largest gift gallery in the Finger Lakes, with work from more than 200 Finger Lakes artisans — pottery, hand-blown glass, wood, sculpture, metal, paintings, photography, jewelry, fabric art, candles, soaps, and locally made food. The official site lists shipping, free wrapping, and gift cards.
Visit the official site
3900 Route 14A, Penn Yan
The Windmill Farm & Craft Market
More than 175 indoor and outdoor shops on 44 acres just south of Penn Yan, including handmade work. Open Saturdays in season; in 2026 the last days are Black Friday, November 27, and Saturday, November 28, per the official site.
Visit the official site
Local art gifts
For a gift that hangs on the wall instead of going in the pantry, Lakes & Tiers Gallery is a new online marketplace for original art and limited-edition prints from Finger Lakes and Southern Tier artists, browsable by lake or by the Southern Tier. Sales are opening soon; you can join the waitlist to hear when buying opens.
Are you a Finger Lakes or Southern Tier artist? The gallery is taking applications from founding artists — listing is free. See join as a founding artist.
Lakes & Tiers Gallery shares an owner with this guide. We do not earn a commission on gallery sales.
More local gifts
Pair a piece of art with something to eat or pour: see local food gifts, wine-country gifts, and the 2026 holiday guide. For handmade and art gifts from across the state, see Shop New York State’s art and local gifts.
Framing and display
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Amazon links on this page use the site tag and are disclosed on the disclosure page.
More gift guides
2026 holiday gifts
Wine-country gifts
Local food gifts
Lake-life gifts
Keuka Lake
Seneca Lake
Cayuga & Canandaigua
Maple
Cheese
Crafts & the Penn Yan market