Maple is a late-winter crop bottled for year-round gifting. Grades and flavors vary by producer and by when the sap ran; official shops will describe what they bottle now.
Canandaigua
Timber Trails Forest Farm
Family-owned 250-acre farm making limited batches of organic, wood-fired maple syrup. Address listed on the official site: 5585 County Road 33, Canandaigua. The farm also describes a carbon-neutral, electric process alongside the traditional wood-fired one. Confirm current jars and visits on the official sugar shop.
Visit the official site
Naples
The Naples Maple Farm
At the Wohlschlegel estate in Naples, in the Canandaigua Lake watershed. The official site says the current sugar house was built in September 2010 and that the operation now has more than 4,200 taps. Grade A Golden through Very Dark syrup and related gifts are sold from the official store.
Visit the official site
Mecklenburg
Steinhaus Farm
Henry and Grit Phelps run a small farm in Mecklenburg, between Ithaca and Watkins Glen. Their house and sugar shack are built by hand from field stone. The official site describes small-batch maple syrup and how to get in touch to order.
Visit the official site
Statewide directory
New York State Maple Producers Association
The producers’ association is the practical directory if you want syrup from a particular Finger Lakes county or a sugarhouse you can visit in season. Start at the official association site.
Visit the official site
Picnic and tasting extras
The makers above sell the gifts themselves. If you also need a simple carrier or a board for a tasting at home, these Amazon searches are a practical add-on — not a substitute for a bottle or a wheel from the farm.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Amazon links on this page use the site tag and are disclosed on the disclosure page.
More gift guides
2026 holiday gifts
Wine-country gifts
Local food gifts
Lake-life gifts
Art & local gifts
Keuka Lake
Seneca Lake
Cayuga & Canandaigua
Cheese
Crafts & the Penn Yan market